How To Scare A Whole Country With Dataviz

Notes, links, and follow up materials for the Visualization in Science and Education, Gordon Research Conference.

Thank you for the opportunity to share. Notes and materials are below for reference.

Related Material

Related Original Research

Must Be A Tuesday: Affect, Attribution, and Geographic Variability in Equity-Oriented Visualizations of Population Health Disparities

Collaboration with Lace Padilla, examining equitable data design techniques for population mortality charts.

Research Paper
Must Be A Tuesday: Affect, Attribution, and Geographic Variability in Equity-Oriented Visualizations of Population Health Disparities

VIS Talk
Must Be A Tuesday
Presentation for IEEE VIS 2024

Dispersion vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes

Collaboration with Cindy Xiong Bearfield, exploring the impact of variability on attribution and stereotypes.

Research Paper
Dispersion vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes

Nightingale
Unfair Comparisons: How Visualizing Social Inequality Can Make It Worse

Study Details
Dispersion vs Disparity Research Project

Motivation
What Can Go Wrong? Deficit Thinking in Dataviz
A collaboration with Pieta Blakely

VIS Talk
Dispersion vs Disparity
Presentation for IEEE VIS 2022

Polarizing Political Polls: How Visualization Design Choices Can Shape Public Opinion and Increase Political Polarization

Collaboration with Cindy Xiong Bearfield, exploring how social normative influences are triggered by charts.

Research Paper
Polarizing Political Polls: How Visualization Design Choices Can Shape Public Opinion and Increase Political Polarization

Nightingale
Divisive Dataviz: How Political Data Journalism Divides Our Democracy

Study Details
Polarizing Political Polls Research Project

Background
Through a Partisan Lens: How Prior Political Beliefs Override Information.

VIS Talk
Polarizing Political Polls IEEE VIS 2023 Talk

Talk Notes

Introduction

Sensemaking is social.

We read charts through our social priors.

Asch 1955
Opinions and Social Pressure

Holder & Xiong 2023
Polarizing Political Polls: How Visualization Design Choices Can Shape Public Opinion and Increase Political Polarization

Why can't we have nice things?

Conventional disparity charts misplace blame.

They blame people, not systems.

Jhangiani & Tarry 2022
Other Determinants of Helping

Nelson & Kinder 1996
Issue Frames and Group-Centrism in American Public Opinion

Rigby et al 2009
Public Responses to Health Disparities: How Group Cues Influence Support for Government Intervention

Snowden & Graaf 2019
The 'Undeserving Poor,' Racial Bias, and Medicaid Coverage of African Americans

Brown-Iannuzzi et al 2016
The Relationship Between Mental Representations of Welfare Recipients and Attitudes Toward Welfare

Metzl 2019
Dying of Whiteness: How the Politics of Racial Resentment is Killing America's Heartland

Attwell et al 2018
‘The Unhealthy Other’ How vaccine rejecting parents construct the vaccinating mainstream

Jhangiani & Tarry 2022
Biases in Attribution

Holder & Xiong 2022
Dispersion vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes

Holder & Padilla 2024
Must Be a Tuesday: Affect, Attribution, and Geographic Variability in Equity-Oriented Visualizations of Population Health Disparities

Social groups can be nonsense, but still influential.

Social categories become real when we use them.

powell & Menendian 2024
Belonging without Othering The Story of our Future

Tajfel et al 1971
Social categorization and intergroup behaviour

Rhodes et al 2012
Cultural transmission of social essentialism

Elliott 2016
A collar in my pocket: The blue-eyes, brown-eyes exercise

Gould 1996
The Mismeasure of Man

Braveman & Dominguez 2021
Abandon 'Race.' Focus on Racism.

Butler 2024
Whose afraid of gender?

Sherif et al 1961
Intergroup conflict and cooperation:The Robbers Cave experiment

Some charts make people look like a**holes.

Hiding outcome variability promotes harmful stereotypes and misattributions about the groups being visualized.

Jhangiani & Tarry 2022
Social Categorization and Stereotyping

Wilmer & Kerns 2022
What’s really wrong with bar graphs of mean values: variable and inaccurate communication of evidence on three key dimensions

Holder & Xiong 2022
Dispersion vs Disparity: Hiding Variability Can Encourage Stereotyping When Visualizing Social Outcomes

Holder & Padilla 2024
Must Be a Tuesday: Affect, Attribution, and Geographic Variability in Equity-Oriented Visualizations of Population Health Disparities

Harmful stereotypes harm everyone

Charts that stereotype one group, hurt everyone by undermining collective action.

Buskila & Perez 2022
The Impact of Victims’ Imagery On Charity Crowdfunding Campaigns How Photos of Victims Doing Nothing To Help Themselves Elicit Fewer Donations

Zaki & Stellar 2025
Moral Emotions

Gollust & Lynch 2011
Who Deserves Health Care? The Effects of Causal Attributions and Group Cues on Public Attitudes About Responsibility for Health Care Costs

We can do better!

Boundary busting. Blaming systems not people. Counter-stereotypes.

3iap
Codesigning Effective Score Reporting With ETS

D'Ignazio & Klein 2020
Data Feminism

Piff et al 2020
Shifting attributions for poverty motivates opposition to inequality and enhances egalitarianism

Meyer 1967
A Survey of Attitudes of Detroit Negroes After the Riot of 1967

Meyer 1990
Presidential Address: Polling As Politial Science and Polling As Journalism

How did we get here?

Status threat invites fascism.

Charts can be threatening!

Butler 2024
Whose afraid of gender?

Ruisch et al 2025
How the Perceived Moral Trajectory of Society Drives Support for Anti-Democratic Behaviour and Authoritarian Leaders

Rivera-Rodriguez et al 2021
Changing public opinion about gender activates group threat and opposition to feminist social movements among men

Hetey & Eberhardt 2014
Racial Disparities in Incarceration Increase Acceptance of Punitive Policies

Major et al 2016
The threat of increasing diversity Why many White Americans support Trump in the 2016 presidential election

Craig & Richeson 2014
On the Precipice of a “Majority-Minority” America - Perceived Status Threat From the Racial Demographic Shift Affects White Americans’ Political Ideology

Mutz 2019
Status Threat, Not Economic Hardship, Explains the 2016 Presidential Vote

Adler-Nissen & Zarakol 2021
Struggles for Recognition The Liberal International Order and the Merger of Its Discontents

You don't have to be a demagogue to do demagoguery

Winning the attention game incentivizes drama.

Ang 2022
The Birth of a Nation Media and Racial Hate

Quinn 2020
Experimental Effects of “Achievement Gap” News Reporting on Viewers’ Racial Stereotypes, Inequality Explanations, and Inequality Prioritization

Hinnant et al 2011
What makes African American health disparities newsworthy? An experiment among journalists about story framing

Liu 2024
Effects of communicating health disparities using social comparison framing: A comprehensive review

We can do better!

How to stop stirring drama.

Battle-Baptiste & Rusert 2018
WEB Du Bois's Data Portraits Visualizing Black America